Oklahoma’s Universal Preschool Program: Better Than OK

By William T. Gormley, Jr.

Over the past decade, my colleagues and I have produced a series of peer-reviewed articles evaluating the effectiveness of Oklahoma’s universal pre-K program, which President Obama praised in his State of the Union Address. Oklahoma’s program, established in 1998, now reaches approximately three-fourths of the state’s four-year-olds. The “Sooner State” has decided that sooner is better than later when it comes to early childhood education.

Our research has focused on Tulsa, the largest school district in the state. The Tulsa school district was an attractive research site because it serves children from diverse racial and ethnic groups.

When we first visited Tulsa, we had reason to believe that the Tulsa pre-K program would be successful. Unlike many other preschool programs, Oklahoma mandates high quality, at least in terms of educational inputs: every lead teacher must have a B.A. degree, must be early childhood certified, and must be paid a public school wage. A child-staff ratio of 10/1 ensures that each child receives personal attention.

As it turns out, our hunch was correct. In fact, the Tulsa pre-K program has generated phenomenal improvements in school readiness. If we look at students as a whole, kindergarten students who attended the Tulsa pre-K program are 9 months ahead of their peers in reading, 7 months ahead in writing, and 5 months ahead in math.

Both disadvantaged and middle-class students experience statistically significant and substantively significant gains in test scores. Disadvantaged students benefit more, but middle-class students also benefit considerably.

Gains are especially striking for English language learners – specifically, Hispanic students whose parents were born in Mexico. For Hispanic children whose parents primarily speak Spanish at home, pre-K participants scored 12 months better than their control group in reading, 4 months better in writing, and 10 months better in math. We also see statistically significant and substantively significant gains in test scores for whites, blacks, and Native Americans.

Thanks to an in-depth investigation of preschool classrooms, we know that what is happening in Tulsa is not magic – it is good, solid teaching. Using Robert Pianta’s instrument for observing classroom dynamics, we found that Tulsa’s pre-K teachers provide higher levels of “instructional support” than their counterparts in school-based pre-K programs in 11 other states. Using another instrument, we found that Tulsa’s pre-K teachers devote more classroom time to reading and math than their counterparts elsewhere.

We also know that the Tulsa pre-K program is producing some socio-emotional impacts. In concrete terms, we found that kindergarten students who participated in pre-K were more attentive and less timid than kindergarten students who did not participate in pre-K. Unlike some national child care studies, we found that participation in the Tulsa pre-K program produced no negative socio-emotional effects.

Since our studies were published, we have received many questions, some praise, and some criticism.

One persistent criticism is this: if Oklahoma’s pre-K program is so fantastic, then why haven’t Oklahoma’s NAEP scores increased sharply as a result? Shikha Dalmia and Lisa Snell of the Reason Foundation and Lindsey Burke of the Heritage Foundation have raised this question, noting that 4th grade reading scores have actually declined in Oklahoma since universal pre-K was introduced.

The first problem with this critique is that NAEP scores are more useful for describing state and national trends than for evaluating state policy interventions. Sweeping conclusions about  preschool based on NAEP data ignore other public policies that profoundly affect the performance of Oklahoma’s school students. One of these is the level of state funding for K-12 education.  Whereas Oklahoma ranks extremely high in both pre-K access and pre-K quality, it ranks extremely low (in the bottom five nationally) in financial support for K-12 public schools. Without a substantial infusion of state funds, it would be difficult, though not impossible, for Oklahoma to improve its 4th and 8th grade test scores.

A second problem with the critique is more subtle. It assumes that an intervention, like a pre-K program, will produce 4th grade effects as soon as the first cohort of participants reaches 4th grade. Unfortunately, 4th grade test scores depend not just on exposure to pre-K but also on any changes in pedagogy that take place in K-3 classrooms. In practice, it probably takes a while for K-3 teachers to adjust their habits and expectations to reflect the new surge in pre-K enrollments. Our latest evidence from Tulsa is consistent with this hypothesis.  When we investigated the persistence of positive pre-K program effects on 3rd grade test scores for the earliest cohort in our data base (students who participated in pre-k in 2000-01), we found no difference between pre-K participants and non-participants. However, when we investigated this for our latest cohort (students who participated in pre-K in 2005-06), we did find persistent differences between pre-K participants and non-participants through 3rd grade. In short, it takes a few years for a school system to adapt to the potentially powerful changes wrought by a high-quality pre-K program.

A different criticism of our Tulsa findings is that our research design falls short of the high standards established by randomized experiments, such as the Perry Preschool and Carolina Abecedarian Projects. The rigorous research design we employed, considered novel at the time, was a “regression discontinuity” strategy for estimating the effects of early childhood education, which took advantage of a strict September 1 birthday cutoff for determining preschool eligibility. By comparing children whose parents decided to enroll them in the school-based pre-K program but who differed in their date of birth, we were able to focus exclusively on students who had just completed pre-K and on students who were about to begin pre-K. This is an excellent way to reduce “selection bias” because the treatment group and the control group both participated in the same pre-K program, albeit at different times.

Of course, we also controlled for each student’s precise date of birth, because older students generally do better on standardized tests than younger students, and for many other variables as well.

To some critics, like Grover Whitehurst of the Brookings Institution, our regression discontinuity design is problematic. Whitehurst cites the hypothetical example of two adopted children who are roughly similar in age but one qualifies for pre-K a year earlier than the other. Won’t parents try to give the slightly older child cognitive and play experiences that help him or her to keep up with older peers at school? If so, it might not be fair to compare the two children.

This is a reasonable hypothesis, but it is only that. The opposite hypothesis, suggested by others, would be that parents focus more assiduously on the child who just missed the pre-K cutoff, in an effort to compensate for delayed entry into preschool.

The bottom line is that our treatment group children and our control group children are strikingly similar in their observable characteristics, even before applying statistical controls. This suggests that our regression discontinuity design is working and working well.

Although we strongly prefer our regression discontinuity approach when studying short-term effects, we have also utilized other techniques, like OLS regression and propensity score matching, to estimate our model. Whichever technique we use, the positive effects of the Tulsa pre-K program are clear and unmistakable.

Because students from recent pre-K cohorts in Tulsa have not yet become adults, it is impossible to say for sure whether the changes wrought by Oklahoma’s universal pre-K program will eventually yield higher earnings and other favorable outcomes. However, by integrating Tulsa kindergarten test scores with Tennessee data linking kindergarten test scores to adult earnings, we have projected that the adult earnings benefits of the Tulsa pre-K program are likely to exceed the costs by 3 to 1 or 4 to 1. Were we to include criminal justice effects, the benefit-cost ratio could be even higher.

There is much more to be learned from Oklahoma, Georgia, Chicago, Boston, and other research sites where high-quality pre-K programs have been made available to large numbers of students. Scholars and activists should continue to scrutinize the empirical research on early childhood education. At the same time, we should not allow skeptics to blind us from the central message of many well-designed empirical studies: a high-quality preschool education benefits children in the short run, especially disadvantaged children, and benefits society as a whole in the long run. That is the key insight animating President Obama’s universal pre-K initiative, and it has been validated by plenty of credible scientific research.

William T. Gormley, Jr. is professor of public policy at Georgetown University and has served as the Co-Director of the Center for Research on Children in the U.S. since 2001.


'Oklahoma’s Universal Preschool Program: Better Than OK' have 30 comments

  1. May 7, 2014 @ 2:02 pm Lessons for K-12 From Pre-K Classrooms | Perspectives |

    […] the same time, new data from high-quality state pre-K programs – Oklahoma’s universal pre-K, New Jersey’s Abbott program and Boston Public Schools’ pre-K – echo early benefits seen in […]


  2. May 12, 2014 @ 2:06 pm Web Hosting

    I have been surfing on-line more than 3 hours
    lately, yet I never found any attention-grabbing article like yours.
    It’s pretty price enough for me. Personally, if all webmasters
    and bloggers made just right content as you probably did, the
    net will be much more helpful than ever before.


  3. June 9, 2014 @ 9:47 pm Carolyn

    Hi, I check your blog on a regular basis. Your story-telling style is awesome, keep up the good work!


  4. June 10, 2014 @ 10:55 am Edmundo

    I couldn’t refrain from commenting. Perfectly written!


  5. June 20, 2014 @ 10:59 pm hack game ios

    Generally I don’t read article on blogs,
    but I wish to say that this write-up very compelled me to check out and do it!
    Your writing style has been amazed me. Thank you, quite great


  6. June 26, 2014 @ 2:15 am Torsten

    It’s actually a great and helpful piece of info. I am glad that you just shared this useful info with us. Please stay us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.


  7. June 29, 2014 @ 2:07 am

    It’s remarkable to go to see this web site and reading the views of all mates concerning this article, while I am also zealous of getting

    - cliquez ici
    - cliquez ici
    - cliquez ici
    - cliquez ici
    - cliquez ici
    - cliquez ici


  8. June 29, 2014 @ 11:57 pm Bruno

    Howdy are using WordPress for your site platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and create my own. Do you need any coding knowledge to make your own blog? Any help would be greatly appreciated!


  9. July 1, 2014 @ 8:44 pm goodgame empire cheats

    Hi there! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow you if that would be ok.
    I’m absolutely enjoying your blog and look forward to
    new posts.


  10. July 1, 2014 @ 9:29 pm Jay

    I’ve learn a few good stuff here. Certainly value bookmarking for revisiting. I surprise how much effort you set to create this kind of excellent informative web site.


  11. July 4, 2014 @ 10:05 am Shane

    Good way of telling, and fastidious piece of writing to take
    facts on the topic of my presentation subject, which i am going to deliver in institution of higher education.


  12. July 10, 2014 @ 9:11 am Lupe

    Asking questions are in fact pleasant thing if you are not understanding something totally, but this piece of writing gives good understanding even.


  13. July 11, 2014 @ 2:05 am

    Heya i am for the first time here. I found this board
    and I in finding It truly useful & it helped me out a lot.
    I hope to give something again and aid others such as you helped me.

    - cliquez ici
    - cliquez ici
    - cliquez ici
    - cliquez ici
    - cliquez ici
    - cliquez ici


  14. July 17, 2014 @ 11:41 am genus Cetorhinus

    Greetings I am so thrilled I found your blog page, I
    really found you by mistake, while I was looking on Bing for something else, Nonetheless I am here now and would just like to say cheers for a incredible post and a all round enjoyable blog
    (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to look over it all at the moment but I have saved it and also
    included your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to
    read a great deal more, Please do keep up the superb


  15. July 18, 2014 @ 1:57 pm

    Yesterday, while I was at work, my sister stole my iphone and tested to see if it can survive a
    twenty five foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad is now broken and she has 83 views.
    I know this is totally off topic but I had to share it with someone!


  16. July 20, 2014 @ 11:55 am Britney

    Hmm it appears like your site ate my first comment (it was extremely long)
    so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I wrote and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog.
    I as well am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new to everything.
    Do you have any helpful hints for rookie blog writers? I’d genuinely appreciate it.


  17. July 20, 2014 @ 10:24 pm

    What’s up, for all time i used to check weblog posts here in the early hours in the morning, since i enjoy to
    gain knowledge of more and more.


  18. July 21, 2014 @ 12:03 am bricebryanlaw

    For most up-to-date news you have to go to see web and on the web I found this
    web site as a best web site for most recent updates.


  19. July 21, 2014 @ 10:15 pm Stop premature ejaculation

    Think about them ɑnd how ʏou сan please them to avoid mental overload.
    Ԝe maу սse a lot because as ѕoon as it wears օff ԝе rreapply
    it. Ѕhе went on to ѕay, “I sit right at the front desk, I would have caught the first bullet.


  20. July 22, 2014 @ 1:39 am real estate asheville nc

    Some real estate companies specialize in farmland, and
    you should check those frequently for property
    listings. Failing to tell a potential buyer that a
    home is haunted in a state where mums the word may exempt you from disclosure, but
    down the road you could still get slapped with a lawsuit if a
    particularly freaked out person ends up not being able
    to live in the house due to the presence of an over bearing entity.
    Compare the amounts that the agents tell you with the
    existing real estate price and consider the comparison as one of the parameters to choose particular agent in the end.


  21. July 22, 2014 @ 6:59 pm Gulshan Bellina Reviews

    7 percent additional ammount and allotment of 10 percent of the developed
    residential plots as compensation to the farmers, Greater Noida and Noida authorities has
    issued notices to all the construction companies whose residential property were in the disputed locations.
    5 lakh of the housing development are seen to be under construction while approximately 1.
    The local realtors believe that the projects in near completion stage,
    industrial and business development and reasonable cost compared to constructed these localities are the main reasons
    why new residential projects are on an increase.


  22. July 22, 2014 @ 9:41 pm Moviestarplanet

    You may want to consider the option of hiring a Link building Companies firm as they offer great prices as well as high quality services.
    Customers just need to fill all his requirements and most
    importantly his budget and the site would provide
    the information matching customer. Choose the keyword that is highly used in search engines.


  23. July 22, 2014 @ 11:17 pm moviestarplanete

    They are not very effective when your site doesn’t have much authority or visibility, as the powerful boost
    a link wheel gives the site might look suspicious to Google.
    In viewing my page as a whole, I noticed my posts seemed to be too long.

    Expert writer with many years of experience of writing on a wide variety of


  24. July 23, 2014 @ 6:08 am

    It’s amazing for me to have a site, which is good for my know-how.

    thanks admin


  25. July 23, 2014 @ 2:20 pm crous perigueux

    l’usure. velopper dans la s. plique montres sont parfaites.


  26. July 23, 2014 @ 5:41 pm infusionsoft software training

    This design is spectacular! You certainly know how
    to keep a reader amused. Between your wit and your
    videos, I was almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Great job.
    I really enjoyed what you had to say, and more than that, how you presented it.

    Too cool!


  27. July 24, 2014 @ 9:52 pm

    I currently am using Backlink Profit Monster to automate this process,
    it can save all the manual work and handle
    the submissions on autopilot, there is nothing else like it.
    Essentially, what you have just done is told Access
    2007 to expect hyperlinks to reside within that particular field in your database.
    Furthermore, the very first URL shortening service traces all the way back to 2001, with various developments
    through the years, to date.


  28. July 25, 2014 @ 8:24 pm clash of clans cheats wiki

    Hi there to all, the contents present at this web site are actually remarkable for people experience, well,
    keep up the good work fellows.


  29. July 25, 2014 @ 9:16 pm

    The initial problem which many companies face when they are using both WordPress
    as well as Code – Igniter is when they want to incorporate Code – Igniter functionality into their WordPress theme files.
    Benefits of the framework include secure communication, business management
    tools, mobile app creation and multi-platform compatibility.
    An XDP can also package a PDF file, along with XML
    form and template data.


  30. July 26, 2014 @ 1:57 am Roxana

    Hey there! Quick question that’s entirely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My weblog looks weird when viewing from my apple iphone. I’m trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to fix this problem. If you have any suggestions, please share. Thank you!


Would you like to share your thoughts?

Your email address will not be published.